Page 2 of 3

Re: Referee question

Posted: Tue Jun 11, 2013 10:07 pm
by rox
Harrier1980 wrote:
Harrier1980 wrote:There is a difference between the initial grant, (2 references, can be anyone, member or not of a club) and the renewal (2 references, one must be a club official, and one must not be a club member)
I thought this summed it up?
Yes it does, perfectly. I just don't see this anywhere on the form itself or on any guidance notes. Please point me at the source.

Thanks.

..

Re: Referee question

Posted: Tue Jun 11, 2013 11:26 pm
by Gaz
rox wrote:
IainWR wrote:The quote is incomplete. There is an entire paragraph before the one quoted that deals with grants.
Sorry, I must be thick, but I'm struggling to see this incomplete part. Please quote the part which states that the second referee may be a member of a target shooting club.

Thanks!

..
The full quote:
You must be resident in Great Britain. Members of the applicant’s immediate family, registered firearms dealers, serving police officers and police employees may not act as referees except as set out below in Note 4. A referee should be of good character. A reference should be given freely and not on payment.
Knowledge of the Applicant
3 Except in the case of a club official acting as a referee in accordance with Note 4 below, you should have known the applicant personally for at least two years. Please also state the capacity in which you have known the applicant: eg business or social, employer/employee.
4 If the application is made in respect of a renewal of a firearm certificate for a firearm for target shooting then one referee must be a club official of the approved club named on the applicants firearm certificate. Dealers may act as referees in these circumstances. The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club. For the grant of a certificate it is not essential that one of the referees is a club official.
Taken from Note to Part E on Form 101:
If this is a new application than both referees must have known you personally for at least two years. They must be resident in Great Britain and must not be a member of your immediate family. Registered firearms dealers, serving police officers or police employees cannot be accepted as referees, except as set out below. Referees must be of good character. References must be given freely and not on payment.
If your application is for the renewal of your firearm certificate for a firearm for target shooting then one of the referees must be an offical of the approved club named on your firearm certificate.
A registered firearms dealer may act as a referee in these circumstances. The other referee must not be a member of any target shooting club.
In other words, if you read the form 101 version, Iain is right and on a grant you can have two club members as referees.

I think...

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 10:26 am
by rox
Gaz wrote:The full quote:
You must be resident in Great Britain. Members of the applicant’s immediate family, registered firearms dealers, serving police officers and police employees may not act as referees except as set out below in Note 4. A referee should be of good character. A reference should be given freely and not on payment.
Knowledge of the Applicant
3 Except in the case of a club official acting as a referee in accordance with Note 4 below, you should have known the applicant personally for at least two years. Please also state the capacity in which you have known the applicant: eg business or social, employer/employee.
4 If the application is made in respect of a renewal of a firearm certificate for a firearm for target shooting then one referee must be a club official of the approved club named on the applicants firearm certificate. Dealers may act as referees in these circumstances. The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club. For the grant of a certificate it is not essential that one of the referees is a club official.
Taken from Note to Part E on Form 101:
If this is a new application than both referees must have known you personally for at least two years. They must be resident in Great Britain and must not be a member of your immediate family. Registered firearms dealers, serving police officers or police employees cannot be accepted as referees, except as set out below. Referees must be of good character. References must be given freely and not on payment.
If your application is for the renewal of your firearm certificate for a firearm for target shooting then one of the referees must be an offical of the approved club named on your firearm certificate.
A registered firearms dealer may act as a referee in these circumstances. The other referee must not be a member of any target shooting club.
Gaz wrote:In other words, if you read the form 101 version, Iain is right and on a grant you can have two club members as referees.

I think...
Both examples state unconditionally that the second/other referee must not be a member of a target shooting club. This has also been the advice given by the NRA and of all the clubs I have been involved with for the last 35 years. It also makes logical sense.

If you read 'Note 4' you see that Note 4 sentence 1 has a condition ("If your application is for the renewal"); Note 4 sentence 2 explicitly states that the conditions of sentence 1 apply to it ("in these circumstances"). But there is no such statement or implication for sentence 3 ("The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club."). It stands alone and is unconditional. The form 101 notes are similar. I think you are misinterpretting it.

..

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 12:50 pm
by Yogi GunKanobee
FWIW - I recently applied for, and was granted a FAC. Both of my referees were club members, both of which I have known for about 10 years.

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 1:02 pm
by rox
Yogi GunKanobee wrote:FWIW - I recently applied for, and was granted a FAC. Both of my referees were club members, both of which I have known for about 10 years.
I don't suppose the police specifically check the club membership status of every referee, so in the context of what is the correct interpretation of the rules on referees I don't think this means anything either way.

..

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 1:44 pm
by Yogi GunKanobee
rox wrote:
Yogi GunKanobee wrote:FWIW - I recently applied for, and was granted a FAC. Both of my referees were club members, both of which I have known for about 10 years.
I don't suppose the police specifically check the club membership status of every referee, so in the context of what is the correct interpretation of the rules on referees I don't think this means anything either way.

..
Well, on the Reference form, part B, question 14, it asks "are you are an official of an approved target shooting club". Both of my friends are officials. When I filled out the application, re read the requirements over and over again, just to make sure. For an initial grant, I couldn't see anywhere where it says that a referee / referees should not be members of a club, only on a renewal, where one has to be a club official, and one not a member of any club. But then I'm just a noob, maybe I was lucky.

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 1:56 pm
by rox
Yogi GunKanobee wrote:For an initial grant, I couldn't see anywhere where it says that a referee / referees should not be members of a club, only on a renewal, where one has to be a club official, and one not a member of any club. But then I'm just a noob, maybe I was lucky.
So you also don't consider that the statement "The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club" was applicable in the circumstances. It seems I am alone in reading it this way - well, alone with the former NRA FLO, and the NRA Vice President who has advised me since the 80s.

..

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 1:59 pm
by Yogi GunKanobee
Correct, as the question was about the Grant of an FAC, not a renewal. Perhaps the forms have changed since you applied for your first FAC?

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 2:12 pm
by rox
Yogi GunKanobee wrote:Correct, as the question was about the Grant of an FAC, not a renewal. Perhaps the forms have changed since you applied for your first FAC?
AFAIK I've been looking at the current forms. I don't see that any condition is attached to the statement "The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club" on form 125 Note 4, as I've explained above.

..

Re: Referee question

Posted: Wed Jun 12, 2013 2:21 pm
by Yogi GunKanobee
rox wrote:
Yogi GunKanobee wrote:Correct, as the question was about the Grant of an FAC, not a renewal. Perhaps the forms have changed since you applied for your first FAC?
AFAIK I've been looking at the current forms. I don't see that any condition is attached to the statement "The second referee must not be a member of any target shooting club" on form 125 Note 4, as I've explained above.

..
Well, there you go! I guess when I was granted my FAC, the Force must have been with me! :grin: