Re: New Member looking for a Rifle
Posted: Thu Feb 09, 2012 8:15 pm
I think you will have difficulty finding any of these as a pure commercial transaction with a significant barrel life at that money.
Swing, being the original four-lock front-locking fast-lock-time design, is now a little less popular than others, and you need to be sure that the one you get is OK - if it's a Mk3 or earlier you need someone that knows, and even the 4s and 5s have their quirks. The next development on that line was the Paramount. This has the problem that the primary extraction is done by a cam machined into the receiver. It either works or it doesn't. If it doesn't you can alleviate the problem but you can never fix it. Then came the various RPAs. Some RPAs actually have scarcity value! There are RPA copies around, the best known being the CG Millennium from NZ - an excellent bit of work. Most recently from the Swing lineage comes the INCH action, which is nevertheless nearly a completely new design (there are very few new ideas in rifle actions so that's saying quite a lot) - you are not going to get one S/H for the money you are considering. Grunigs are not common. Others to consider include the AI, designed in consultation with Malcom Cooper; if you can find one the Shilen - a beautiful, elegant, succesful and uncommon design from the world of benchrest in the 1970s; and the Stolle from the same world but rather newer. The Remington 700 has never been fashionable, though it has a good reputation outside of the TR world. I wouldn't go for the PH 1200 - it is a straight copy of the Mauser '98, and the real thing with a new barrel would be as good (and people these days are almost giving them away).
If you want a really good but inexpensive rifle, can I suggest a Musgrave? They aren't fashionable - two main reasons. They come with a single stage trigger as standard, and because the action mounts extend behind the back of the bolt, they tend to be long in the butt. Not a problem if you are a bloke over about 5' 9", or if you own a saw and are prepared to use it. But they are excellent target actions, and can be had for relatively little money on the secondhand market.
Whatever you buy, do remember that the life of a TR barrel is typically 6000-8000 rounds, and that a new barrel plus fitting plus proof will set you back the thick end of £600 (though there are new challengers in that market). If your barrel is shot out and you don't realise it, you will simply expend a load of ammo wondering why you aren't achieving what you feel you should. You need one of two types of expert to tell you; either a good and unbiased gunsmith, or a world-class shot with handloads tuned to your gun on a good day.
Just my thoughts. I have owned a Mauser, two Swings and an RPA, and I look after 4 Swings, 5 Paramounts, 6 RPAs, 4 Musgraves and 2 Shilens for the RAF TRC. Do post if you want more, or PM to be pointed at an expert (which I definitely am not).
Iain
Swing, being the original four-lock front-locking fast-lock-time design, is now a little less popular than others, and you need to be sure that the one you get is OK - if it's a Mk3 or earlier you need someone that knows, and even the 4s and 5s have their quirks. The next development on that line was the Paramount. This has the problem that the primary extraction is done by a cam machined into the receiver. It either works or it doesn't. If it doesn't you can alleviate the problem but you can never fix it. Then came the various RPAs. Some RPAs actually have scarcity value! There are RPA copies around, the best known being the CG Millennium from NZ - an excellent bit of work. Most recently from the Swing lineage comes the INCH action, which is nevertheless nearly a completely new design (there are very few new ideas in rifle actions so that's saying quite a lot) - you are not going to get one S/H for the money you are considering. Grunigs are not common. Others to consider include the AI, designed in consultation with Malcom Cooper; if you can find one the Shilen - a beautiful, elegant, succesful and uncommon design from the world of benchrest in the 1970s; and the Stolle from the same world but rather newer. The Remington 700 has never been fashionable, though it has a good reputation outside of the TR world. I wouldn't go for the PH 1200 - it is a straight copy of the Mauser '98, and the real thing with a new barrel would be as good (and people these days are almost giving them away).
If you want a really good but inexpensive rifle, can I suggest a Musgrave? They aren't fashionable - two main reasons. They come with a single stage trigger as standard, and because the action mounts extend behind the back of the bolt, they tend to be long in the butt. Not a problem if you are a bloke over about 5' 9", or if you own a saw and are prepared to use it. But they are excellent target actions, and can be had for relatively little money on the secondhand market.
Whatever you buy, do remember that the life of a TR barrel is typically 6000-8000 rounds, and that a new barrel plus fitting plus proof will set you back the thick end of £600 (though there are new challengers in that market). If your barrel is shot out and you don't realise it, you will simply expend a load of ammo wondering why you aren't achieving what you feel you should. You need one of two types of expert to tell you; either a good and unbiased gunsmith, or a world-class shot with handloads tuned to your gun on a good day.
Just my thoughts. I have owned a Mauser, two Swings and an RPA, and I look after 4 Swings, 5 Paramounts, 6 RPAs, 4 Musgraves and 2 Shilens for the RAF TRC. Do post if you want more, or PM to be pointed at an expert (which I definitely am not).
Iain